Impactful Tweets (pt 3) ICAN 2011 Conference

I tried to catch as much of the Henci Goer chatter on twitter as I could tonight.  We have a full house tonight (our 3 plus 2 neighbor kids spending the night, oy!) so I’m playing with less than a full deck.  Ha!

Disclaimer: Since I read these tweets on a public hashtag channel, I’m not asking permission to repost.  If anyone wants their tweet removed or wants to clarify a tweet, please let me know.

anderzoid #ICAN2011 henci goer: how much we have over medicalized birth? IV drip- not allowed to eat or drink – induction- cord clamping- etc
I assume this was a slide of the topics used to justify the point that birth is over medicalized.  My previous research leads me to concur that these are some of the ‘biggies.’

poderyparto Ineffective & harmful practices: sonograms to estimate fetal weight, planned cesarean for breech,not supported by research. #ICAN2011
Ultrasound is such a poor diagnostic tool for assessing fetal weight in the 3rd trimester.  I can’t recall exactly ‘when’ ultrasound is more accurate for predicting due ‘dates,’ but it’s very early on – I’m thinking 8-12 weeks gestation, but don’t quote me on that.  Only one mom out of the many I know personally that were told they were going to have a big baby actually did have a big baby.  Friends and family members who have had 3rd trimester estimates done with specialists have birthed babies 2 pounds lighter than predicted!!!!  Regarding the no-questions-asked cesarean for breech – a flawed Canadian study is what dictates current US practice.  Thank goodness Canada is taking the lead to restore breech as a version of normal.

bbybirthingmama Scheduling a section for breech, twins, “big baby” and slow labor are not supported by research! #ICAN2011
I was sad to discover that 75% of twins in Montana are born by cesarean.  I imagine all breeches are born by cesarean except for the rare surprise breech or unattended breech births.  Many docs aren’t ‘allowed’ by their insurance companies to deliver breeches naturally – how convenient for them.  Slow labor – yeah!  Most women just DON’T dilate 1cm/hr.  I REPEAT – MOST WOMEN AREN’T GONNA DILATE ACCORDING TO FRIEDMAN’S CURVE.

tconsciousdoula The way to get a VBAC? Tell the Dr you are planning on having 10 children! #ican2011
Now that’s a good one.  I’ll have to add that one to my list!

babydickey: Perinatal death from csec scar uterine rupture is 6 in 10,000. But did you know pregnancy loss from amniocentesis is 60 in 10,000? #ICAN2011 AND Unnecesarean 6% of scar ruptures—> perinatal death (3 per 10,000). Compare to excess risk of pregnancy loss from amniocentesis… 60 per 10,000. #ICAN2011
Here’s what was stated in the NIH VBAC Report: “Approximately 6 percent of uterine ruptures will result in perinatal death. This is an overall risk of intrapartum fetal death of 20 per 100,000 women undergoing trial of labor. For term pregnancies, the reported risk of fetal death with uterine rupture is less than 3 percent.”

tconsciousdoula planned VBAC should be the norm (87%) actual rate is 9% (2007) #ican2011
Add this information to your notebooks in case you need to make the case for VBAC to a doctor, a nurse, a hospital administrator, or a friend.

tiffrobyn A 41 week pregnancy is not only normal, it is AVERAGE! #ICAN2011
Like . . . duh.  Why have care providers forgotten that?  Well, statistically that may not be the exact average for all childbearing groups (i.e. primip vs. multip), but it’s absolutely ridiculous to pressure a woman into inducing at 41 weeks.  Some providers will start pressuring you at 39 weeks, especially if you let them anywhere near your cervix!

bbybirthingmama WHO Recommends no more than 10% induction rate. I didn’t know that. #ICAN2011 BUT poderyparto US induction rate 2005: 47% (babydickey tweeted 41%) of women planning vaginal birth! #ICAN2011 #CAM2011

shedenka So hospitals and docs tell ALL women “you can’t eat/drink” during labor. Total CYA: aspiration risk is 3.2 women out of 10 million #ICAN2011

nashvillebirth Henci Goer makes my head hurt in a good way. She always melts my face off. #ICAN2011
*Giggle*  This really made me smile.  I love having my brain hurt in a good way.  It’s invigorating!!

bbybirthingmama Early Cord Clamping can take up to 40% of newborns blood volume! #ICAN2011
I had no idea!  All of my babies have had their cords clamped immediately.  I will definitely add this to my notebook – I had decided a while back that I wanted delayed cord clamping.  I know it’s not really a strange thing to ask of a CPM but may be strange for an OB.

anderzoid Henci Goer still on ineffective & HARMFUL practices: Care by an OB for LOW-risk & MODERATE-risk women #ican2011
This point was made by a NYC OB in “The Business of Being Born.”  It’s overkill, and generally speaking, normal birth just isn’t exciting enough for them.  Plus, most of them have never seen a normal birth – especially the younger OBs.

anderzoid: #ICAN2011 #ppdchat Henci Goer: it’s hard to get #PTSD on radar bc TRAUMA is centered in Institution. DEPRESSION is centered in women.
This is a very interesting statement and one that I’d like to have fleshed out for me.  I can almost grasp it but not quite.  I will say that people seem to be aware of PPD and acknowledge it but are less able to grasp PTSD as it relates to childbirth (or pregnancy loss).

Want to read more conference hi-lights?  Here is part 2 and part 1 of my Impactful Tweets “coverage.”

DH & I have a big to do list for the weekend, so I don’t know how thorough future posts will be.  Enjoy the weekend!

EDITED to add “Birthing Beautiful Ideas’s” wrap-up of the day’s presentations at the ICAN 2011 Conference.  Have a look!

Impactful Tweets (pt 2) from ICAN Conference

Looks like @DeepSouthDoula is the winner of cool tweets, part 2.  I’ll have to tell her the amazing news, LoL!  Looks like there will have to be a part 3 tonight.  Henci Goer has already made some great points, and she’s only just gotten started!  w00t!!  Here’s the link to part 1 if you missed that post.

DeepSouthDoula Abdominal scars can change your overall body mechanics for the worse. #ICAN2011
Interesting how people don’t consider what happens to the muscles and especially the connective tissue as a result of this major abdominal surgery.  I’m a professional opera singer and rely on the entire abdominal complex to support my sound.  This includes the pelvic floor.  This entire structure has been permanently altered.  Have you considered how your cesarean might (will) affect you physically?

poderyparto Herrera: People should see a c/s. Once they ser it they’ll start asking more questions. #ICAN2011
This is an interesting statement.  I just don’t imagine your average woman would be interested or even willing to watch a cesarean surgery.  And really, it’s different being in the room when one is happening versus seeing it on TV or YouTube.

Preparing4Birth: #ICAN2011 @ICANtweets Insurance company should not mandate how doc works. Write congressman. A state issue
This is HUGE.  I was aggravated to learn from my OB that his malpractice insurance doesn’t cover vaginal breech delivery.  He’s an older doctor, so of course, he knows how to do it.  I think it is incredibly unfair that my second birth was dictated by someone else’s friggin’ insurance!!!

Ethologicmom #ICAN2011 amazing that dice didn’t realize that women choose or are forced into hbacmom by bans and lack of support!
Dice?  I have no idea.  But yes, women increasingly choose homebirth and unassisted birth because they ultimately feel unsupported by some (or all) careproviders.  A woman who feels forced into homebirth or unassisted birth are not ideal candidates for those settings.  A woman should have access to the care she desires.  We’re the ones paying for it!!!

DeepSouthDoula The only true way to know if you will have a successful VBAC is to try. #ICAN2011
I just can’t imagine not trying . . . even though people would try to scare me out of it.  Fearmongering is not the way to go, folks . . . studying the evidence is!

drpoppyBHRT How do we “grow” supportive providers? #VBAC @BirthingKristin #ICAN2011 #NIHVBAC
I imagine that since newer docs are typically less willing to recommend VBAC (based on NIH VBAC consensus report), that now that the ACOG recommendation has been revised, perhaps the new generation of OBs will be less resistant.  This doesn’t mean we shouldn’t be doing everything we can to positively affect our local birth culture!

DeepSouthDoula Any person pregnant or not has the right to refuse medical treatment – even in an emergency. Goes for refusing CS. #ICAN2011
One of my friends is having her 3rd VBAC after cesarean.  We were performing out of town, and she thought the local hospital didn’t allow VBACs.  She was relieved to learn (from me . . . yay me!) that she did NOT have to consent to a cesarean if she had the misfortune of going into labor in that town.  On the other hand, it would have been an opportunity for us to ‘educate’ that particular hospital on the rights of childbearing women! ;)

DeepSouthDoula Have the NIH & ACOG statements ready & use them to our advantage. #ICAN2011
Great advice!  I’m on Spring Break right now, and honestly, I’m just now getting around to reading the NIH VBAC Consensus report.  Eye opening, really.  I’ve “clipped” out the conclusion summary and points within the detailed section of the statement that directly apply to my situation or to issues that seem most critical to me.  I will be bringing some of this information with me as I interview an OB regarding VBA2C.

DeepSouthDoula SHARE – ORGANIZE – PROMOTE – CHANGE. Make connections through social media. #ICAN2011
Following the #ICAN2011 channel has shown me that a lot of birthies are now quite active on twitter.  I guess I’ll pay more attention to twitter . . . at least for a while.  Birthies and moms are welcome to request to follow me – @labortrials.


Impactful Tweets (pt 1) from ICAN 2011 Conference

I’m taking a break from my “Emotional Clutter” post that I’ve been working on.  Ahhh, nice to take a breather from that topic.  My friend, L, pointed me to http://twitterfall.com as the best hashtag (#) reader out there.  And well, she would know!

So, I’ve been reading the #ICAN2011 channel and want to share some of the tweets that I’ve seen that should make an impact on VBACtivists as we do our important work!  (Since I’m pulling this content from a public channel, I am not asking permission to repost.  I will remove tweets if the OP requests.)

@DeepSouthDoula: [Macones] Be patient and keep working on us (OBs). Things will get better but it will take time. #ICAN2011
This is encouraging to read.  Other tweets indicate that consumers should be addressing hospital administrators.  However, from personal experience I can tell you that our hospital’s CEO said he can’t make the OBs change.  It’s easy for folks to displace and deflect in this business.

@Preparing4Birth: VBAC candidacy – low vertical incision 98% are this type. 1 or 2 prior ces should have access. Birthweight not a predictor. #ICAN2011
I read another tweet that indicated he supports VBA2+C but that it takes the right patient with the right provider in the right hospital.  I’ve also read that the steepest increase in rupture rates is between 1 (.5%) and 2 (1%) cesareans and then begins to level out.

@Unnecesarean: Macones: We’ve all focused so long on uterine rupture but need to also focus on the consequences of multiple cesareans #ICAN2011

@babydickey: We are underestimating the risks of multiple c-sections. #ICAN2011
A great site for weighing the risks of VBAC and repeat cesarean is Childbirth Connection.  Also have a look at the NIH VBAC Consensus.

@ShannonMitchell: When vbac rates CAN be 60-80% Don’t ask me to wait for ten years for a 20% rate #ican2011 #birthaction
I love me some Shannon.  She’s absolutely right, so we all need to get off of our duffs and DO SOMETHING!  Or do MORE!!

@ Unnecesarean: Macones: If hospitals can’t respond to emergencies, they probably don’t have any business doing obstetrics. (attributed to Landon) #ICAN2011
This is a very important point and should be addressed any time a facility with a maternity ward imposes a VBAC ban.  People who live in towns with VBAC bans in place should write letters to the paper, picket the hospital, and set up an on-line petition at the very least.  The average family doesn’t know that a facility that can’t handle a VBAC is unsafe for childbirth.

@ShannonMitchell: From 30 to 32% is 40,000 cesareans #ican2011 #birthaction
Wow, 30-32% is not nearly as offensive as knowing that 40,000 more women were cut open . . . many (most?) unnecessarily!  And other tweets indicate that the 40K cuts refer to the increase from 32-32.9% (our current national cesarean rate).  If that’s the case, how is that not perceived as a national crisis????

@tiffrobyn: Dr Macones: ECV, CVS testing, carry 1-2% risk, greater than vbac. #ICAN2011
Tests and procedures (including cesareans) that OBs may offer are sometimes riskier than what they refuse to do (attend VBAC).  I will say that I’ve never been offered an amnio, ECV, or CVS even at my advanced maternal age. ;)

More later, I am certain . . .

Cesarean Awareness Month 2011

© Amy Swagman, 2010 -www.themandalajourney.com

© Amy Swagman, 2010 -www.themandalajourney.com

So another year has passed, and I’m back to wondering where we are with our cesarean awareness ‘campain.’  I’m somewhat ‘skirting’ the loop (not really inside or outside of it, just around), so I’m not your most up to date source.  For truly outstanding resources related to cesarean awareness, read Unnecessarean and VBAC facts for starters!

A couple of things that have my attention lately:

  • Our national cesarean rate is staggering, and some predict that by 2020, 1/2 of our births will be done by cesarean.  We must be vigilant!
  • Montana needs a Friends of Montana Midwives group
  • Montana’s cesarean rate is 29% just below the national average.  However, some counties in MT have super high cesarean rates.  Why is that? (Carter County had a 65.4% c/s rate 2005-08 according to the March of Dimes!!!!)
  • Birth activist are working so hard – it’s just awesome!  Thank you to all who are gettin’ it done!!
  • According to Childbirth Connection, “A high-quality, high-value maternity care system is within reach, and childbearing women are the most important stakeholders to drive system change.”  Have a look and see what you can do!
  • Also, through Childbirth Connection, I’ve learned about relevant legislation that has been introduced.  This legislation needs our support!!
  • ICAN is getting ready for the 2011 conference – wish I could be there . . .

Because I’m pregnant I’m in a great position to find out even more about what is being done locally and what still needs work.  I have found – contrary to what my OB told me – that a few OBs will consider VBA2C on a case by case basis.  I have discovered that our only independent birth center, run by a fantastic CNM, does VBACs (even primary!) but not VBAmC.  I have lots of friends who are pregnant these days and have learned a lot about local practices.

Because I’m pregnant with #4 and work a full time job (one that often has me out of town on weekends in the Spring and has me out at night), I haven’t had the time & energy to get more aggressive.  This too shall change, and when it does – LOOK OUT!  ;)

In the meantime . . . what can you do?

Today’s Notable Reads

Today is a banner day on my Facebook news feed.  Here are some things that piqued my interest.

  • Owen Wilson and his girlfriend welcomed their baby into the world at home!  I’m not providing a link – I figure you can go to your favorite celeb site if you’re curious.  ;)
  • Did you know that nearly 100% of us parents use car seats incorrectly.  Here’s a 5-minute video featuring “The Car Seat Lady.”
  • I haven’t read this yet, but check out this New Yorker article regarding the decline effect and the scientific method.
  • Homebirth: A Midwife Mutiny is a great blog.  I first read Risk, homebirth, VBAC and am now on to her take on a BBC News article about “womb tearing.”  Next, I think I’ll read Blaming Women, because HELLO it happens all the stinkin’ time.
  • I’m also curious to read a new-to-me blog today, particularly the article on “No, Actually, You Did Not Turn Out Ok.”  We’ll see – I’m a fairly mainstream mama, so I don’t know how I’ll respond knowing that this is one of the blogger’s perspectives: “Where I Post . . . And Kick Your Lily White Arse For Making Your Baby Cry-It-Out.”  We ended up doing CIO with our oldest.  Is she ok – not completely.  Is it because of CIO – not necessarily.  Are we ok – no completely.  Is it because of CIO – not exactly.  But hey, let’s blame ourselves (see blaming women above) and each other (a favorite past-time for some on Facebook) for our kids becoming assholes or freaks as if THEY have nothing to do with it.
  • DEEP BREATH
  • My favorite spot on the internet for sound pregnancy & birth related advice – Childbirth Connection

Feeling Overwhelmed . . . hmm

I’m feeling overwhelmed this week.  Icky.

A couple of things have thrown me off my center, perhaps.  Like my good friend’s threatened labor now at 30w gestation.  Like my sister-in-law’s straight-forward CBAC yesterday – don’t get me wrong, I’m thankful, but it’s still affecting me.  Like having to go back to work in less than two weeks – survival mode.  Like all of the projects that I haven’t accomplished this winter break.  Like my birthday coming tomorrow – gross late-30s number!  Like CBA2C vs. VBA2C vs. CBA2C vs. VBA2C and on and on.

Ack.

What do you do when you’re feeling overwhelmed and ineffective?  Any suggestions?  It’s really causing me to stagnate and procrastinate.

It’s not like I’m doing absolutely NOTHING.  It’s just that I feel like I’m hiding in my birth research and stressing about a lot of different things and not actually accomplishing things in a timely fashion.  I just need to break the cycle.  I probably need a to do list – maybe a reward chart?!  Haha!

We already feel inadequate

I watched Orgasmic Birth last night on Amazon.  When I told my husband what I was watching, he gave me a look like “oh no, you’re going to be one of those women this time, huh?”  I told him that despite the title, the movie was supposed to be good, and for the most part it was.

If you go to the OG website, you’ll see that they define the word orgasmic differently than you would expect: “Intense or unrestrained excitement or a similar point of intensity or emotional excitement.”  I’d agree that all of the normal physiologic births shown on the video demonstrated intensity.  It’s important to read the definition above with the word “or” in mind.  A woman does not have to achieve orgasm during labor/birth to have an orgasmic birth.

I found it interesting that one of the interviewed NCB experts suggested that we don’t share our birth stories because we don’t want to make other women feel inadequate.  Perhaps a woman who consents to an epidural in a hospital setting will feel inadequate, I don’t know.  But, a woman who has undergone a cesarean after trying to labor will almost always feel inadequate in some way.  (I know there are always women out there who will say different.)  Let me explain.

A woman is told that babies come out of vaginas, and that most of the time that is possible.  Women may enter into the last stages of pregnancy knowing that they want an epidural or to be induced, but they still expect that in most cases, the baby is going to come out normally.  However, most hospital birthers are not given the right kind of support to achieve a natural physiologic birth or normal birth.  Inductions are fairly normal.  Augmentations are fairly normal.  Epidurals are extremely common.  As one expert pointed out on the movie, when most (like 90%) laboring women receive an epidural, and you don’t, you take the staff out of its comfort zone.

So after these interventions and more (constant monitoring, restricted movement in labor, etc.), women are still expected somehow to birth vaginally.  And a third of us are sectioned – or more, depending on the location.  Our bodies failed us, we are lead to believe.  “Thank God I was in the hospital or my baby and I would have been in big trouble.”  Our inadequacies are magnified by the overwhelming successes of the medical machine.

Women who have had cesareans are defensive.  “My cesarean was necessary” is a common belief.  But to suggest that women don’t share their birth stories because they don’t want to make a cesarean mother feel inadequate is not understanding the situation.  We already feel inadequate.

I am 1 of 3 women sectioned in childbirth.

I am one of numerous women told that her body wasn’t capable of birthing her baby.

I am 3 of 4 women sectioned in Montana for twins.

I am nearly 100% of women in my community told they cannot have a VBAC in the hospital after multiple scars.

I am nearly 100% of women told to be thankful that they have a healthy baby after a cesarean section.

Share your birth stories in a supportive, instructive, and hopeful manner.  Give cesarean mamas hope that next time can be different, if she chooses.  And she has to choose; you can’t choose for her.  I myself am preparing for a transformational experience this summer.  I can’t get there unless I embrace stories of uninhibited natural physiologic birth.